Hello dear
Welcome To Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill
Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill, located in the scenic New Shoreham, Rhode Island, is a culinary gem celebrated for its fresh, flavorful seafood and delightful atmosphere. This charming establishment offers a diverse menu featuring highlights such as creamy lobster bisque, succulent lamb lollipops, and pan-seared scallops, designed to tantalize your taste buds. Guests rave about the welcoming service and the beautiful garden setting, perfect for a relaxing dining experience. With carefully curated cocktails and a thoughtful wine selection, Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill stands out as a must-visit destination for food lovers seeking quality and ambiance.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Lobster Bisque
Schreckbichl Colterenzeio Alta
Rabble - Paso Robles
Domaine Fay D'homme Muscadet
About
Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill
Welcome to the delightful world of Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of New Shoreham, Rhode Island. Located at 251 Spring St, this charming establishment offers a unique dining experience that celebrates both the local flavors and the beauty of its surroundings.
Imagine dining in a beautiful garden setting, where the fresh ocean air mingles with the aroma of expertly crafted dishes. The ambiance here is relaxing, making it the perfect spot for a laid-back dinner or a special celebration. Customers rave about the generous bread basket, featuring warm ciabatta rolls paired with a luscious orange zested butter, setting the tone for what’s to come.
Diving into the Menu, the offerings at Block Island are nothing short of exquisite. Guests have enthusiastically recommended the lamb lollipops and pan-seared scallops, both praised for their exceptional flavors. The seafood options truly shine, with dishes like miso glazed cod and swordfish leaving diners in awe. One highlight shared by patrons is the oysters Thermidorian—creamy, flavorful, and a must-try, as highlighted by Brian, who described them as melting in your mouth.
The salads also deserve a mention, with choices ranging from Caesar to unique offerings like the Watermelon Salad and Strawberry Fields Forever, catering to every palate. For those who enjoy a glass of wine with their meal, the carefully curated selections of Sauvignon Blanc and Rosé—including favorites like Whispering Angel and Kim Crawford—perfectly complement the seafood dishes.
A Personal Touch is what truly elevates the experience at Block Island. Reviewers often mention the attentive and friendly staff, who go above and beyond to make each guest feel welcomed. Kimberly, one of the esteemed servers, has made quite an impression by simply stopping by for a chat, enhancing the dining experience with her warm presence.
The sweet endings at Block Island are not to be overlooked. The caramel cheesecake is a highlight, enjoyed alongside a freshly crafted cappuccino—though a touch warmer would have been perfect, as one guest noted. Nevertheless, the perfect combination of delicious desserts and friendly service ensures that visitors leave with happy memories.
Based on glowing reviews from guests like Bruce and Lindsey, it’s easy to see why Block Island Oyster Bar and Grill is a must-visit. The combination of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, coupled with a picturesque setting and attentive service, creates a memorable dining experience time and time again.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, be sure to stop by for a meal that promises to be both delightful and satisfying. You won’t just experience the food; you’ll embrace the essence of Block Island itself.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Made reservations ahead of time. Plenty of room for dinner. No cocktail menu but they will make whatever you like. Got a blackberry mojito and red sangria. Both quite tasty. Everything ciabatta rolls with orange zested butter tasted great. Got the lamb lollipops and the pan seared scallops for apps, both tastes amazing. Picked the miso glazed cod and the swordfish dish....awesome!!! Finished off the evening with the caramel cheesecake and cappuccinos. Cappuccinos were barely warm (didn’t steam the milk long enough to heat it up). Fresh whooped cream with the cheesecake and Carmel that didn’t taste like butterscotch...awesome. Service was great from the staff. Presentations were great. Would definitely come here again on our next visit to Block Island. ”
“ First of all, the beautiful garden setting just sets the tone for a relaxing dinner. The generous bread basket was delicious. All of us chose the salmon with steamed vegetables. I had my salmon blackened it was absolutely delicious. Kimberly stopped by to check on us and stayed for a little conversation. She always makes sure you are very welcomed and happy. I would highly recommend coming here. ”
“ Food was fantastic and clearly fresh - atmosphere is a bit dated - but that may be what they are going for - but who cares about atmosphere when you’re eating delicious food! ”
“ Everything was fantastic. The ambience was perfect. It was so pretty. All of the food was delicious. The staff were great. I would highly recommend. ”
“ We visited the Oyster Bar and Grill in the beginning of September. The atmosphere was set on a open lawn with beautiful views and free roaming chickens. We have recently moved from Australia to America and this was by far the nicest meal we’ve had. Our server Sydney was very welcoming and gave wonderful recommendations. We shared a bunch of different starters which we recommend as they were all mouth watering. We had the oysters Thermidorian (10/10) which were creamy, full of flavor and the lobster on top melted on your tongue. The lobster bisque was buttery, and the scallops with candied pancetta on top of apple was my personal favorite. All around a must visit when coming to visit. ”
“ Listen, I don't write a lot of reviews because there aren't too many places with reviewing beyond saying "this is good" or "avoid this". This place is worth the high price tag. Ate there twice, every item from appetizer to dessert and drinks was excellent. The location is fantastic as well in the ground level of the Mannessee, try to have dinner outside on the patio by the fountain, the night lighting is excellent. Great live music as well on one of the nights we went. ”
“ Dinner was with 9 people. Nice upscale place. Enchanting environment with lights and great outdoor views. We got a bunch of appetizers to share, such as the stuffed portabello, stuffed clams, bread basket, and tuna tacos, lamb lollipops. They were all great. Nice seasonings, and good for sharing. For the entre I got the strawberry salad with steak strips. The salad portion was amazing The lettuce was tender and smothered wi th goat cheese, strawberry, and seasoning. The steak was alright. It was a bit tough and not as well seasoned. However, everything else was absolutely incredible. The dessert was great, too. We got a variety. The key lime pie was very nice and tart. The flourless chocolate cake was dense and rich. However, the best was the white chocolate mousse. It had a bunch of delicious layers. Nice waiters. Reasonable wait time. Would absolutely recommend for people in the Block Island Area looking for a nice dinner ”
“ So good, beautiful room, feels like Martha Stewart Hamptons Summer White decor, great food, super friendly service, will definitely go again next visit to the Island. ”